Kickstarter launched on April 28, 2009. The first game I backed on Kickstarter was Alien Frontiers in April 2010. I am not sure if anyone expected “Games” to be the most successful category for Kickstarter. Kickstarter has been great for me personally, as I have backed over 600 projects and really enjoyed seeing most of the projects come to fruition.
Kickstarter has been very good for Fort Circle. We have run six campaigns and raised a total of $519,351:
The Shores of Tripoli - $44,204
Votes for Women - $29,792
The Halls of Montezuma - $55,140
Votes for Women (second printing) -$194,361
Hunt for Blackbeard - $62,597
First Monday in October - $133,437
Four of the campaigns have successfully concluded, First Monday in October is fulfilling now and The Halls of Montezuma is heading to the printers. Being able to crowdfund has had a number of benefits:
A Unique Sales Channel: Kickstarter brings a base of customers looking for new games. Although crowdfunding’s shine has dimmed some lately because some campaigns have had a disappointing final product or even in some cases not fulfilling at all, it remains a strong sales channel.
A Sense of Urgency: Even though we disdain the ickier marketing tactics that prey on people’s fear of missing out, the very time-limited nature of a campaign can encourage sales.
Sales Forecasting: The Kickstarter numbers obviously can help forecast demand for a game in its first year. This helps me determine the quantity for the first print run.
Cash Flow: The prepayment for about 20% of each print run certainly eased cash flow considerations early in the company’s history, although this is not really a consideration anymore.
Unfortunately, there have been two changes that have made us reconsider how we utilize Kickstarter. The first change is that Kickstarter is now viewed as a pre-order platform. Major companies use Kickstarter for games that they know they are going to publish. This is a definite shift away from the older ethos of “hey, I have an idea for a game, but need some help financing the art and development” that previously existed.
The second change is that Kickstarter has lost some of its luster. Some of that was first-time publishers who got in over their heads and could not deliver - I am still sad about the failure of the SeaRovers project. But larger failures like Mythic and CMON have made Kickstarter at times look more like a Ponzi scheme than a legit crowdfunding platform.
Of course, the mess from the IEEPA tariffs certainly exacerbated issues for publishers - including us. We had three outstanding Kickstarters when the tariffs hit: The Halls of Montezuma (2023 KS), Hunt for Blackbeard (2024 KS) and First Monday in October (2024/2025 KS). We exhausted all options for printing alternatives to China - Brazil, Vietnam, Poland, the Netherlands - but nothing worked. Ultimately, we had to wait until the Supreme Court ruled the IEPPA tariffs unconstitutional in February 2026 before restarting production. A little side note, we now pay 15% tariff on our game made in China because we lost a ruling at Customs. We are appealing that ruling.
Of course, we were not the only company to rush back into production - hence there was a pretty significant backlog at our factory. While we expected all three outstanding Kickstarters to deliver in 2026, The Halls of Montezuma will not deliver until early 2027. While it is not entirely our fault, our focus on the highest quality final product has certain added to the delays for Montezuma. I understand it is quite frustrating for our backers. On most campaigns we have two or three people request refunds for various reasons, for The Halls of Montezuma it is almost two dozen refunds. There are five 1-star reviews on Board Game Geek for The Halls of Montezuma with stellar comments like, “Game does not exist. Fort Circle Games cannot be trusted. Will never purchase a game from them again.” Ouch.
So how to proceed with Kickstarter? In some cases, we won’t use Kickstarter. For Night Witches, David and Liz are well-known in the industry and Ian O’Toole is a legendary artist, so there is enough demand from distributors and retailers to determine the size of the first print run. In some cases, we will Kickstart a second printing. For Shakespeare’s First Folio, we are doing a small first printing with a significant portion of those games going to reviewers. Then we will launch a Kickstarter for the second printing to coincide with Shakespeare’s birthday in April. And in some cases, for a less heralded game like Peace 1905, we will go directly to Kickstarter, but only once the game is 100% ready to print at the factory. In all scenarios, there will be no delay between the Kickstarter campaign ending and hitting the print button at the factory. In other words, Kickstarter will now be a pre-order machine for us as well. Of course, we are only in a position to do so because we have very low overhead and adequate access to capital.
A little piece of joy in me dies because of this. The fantasy of Kickstarter being the place a plucky designer can go to get their game funded is dead. Now it’s just business.






I was also someone I feel became a somewhat "early adopter" of the Kickstarter model from the backer side, using it for tabletop games, technology, clothing(!), etc. My unfulfilled rate is under 10% and it never really deterred me from cheering for the underdog and backing so many of these campaigns. It is sad to see such an interesting and creative-forward model become increasingly taken over by larger corporations who lean into (and thrive off) the FOMO angle.
I hope there are still going to be good, sustainable avenues for publishers like Fort Circle to get your games in front of distributor's/FLGS's/gamer's eyes... and eventually tables. I love what you're doing (am waiting for a couple on your active list) and look forward to more of these excellent games getting played by me and others!
I am surprised at the reviews, I am not going to lie and claim I have no frustration at the delays for Halls. But the level of communication from you, and the transparency on finances and history of your company don't warrant those reviews.